WRKF

Twitter Analysis Shows How Trump Tweets Differently About Nonwhite Lawmakers

Oct 10, 2019
Originally published on October 10, 2019 10:08 am

President Trump uses his Twitter feed the way past presidents used the White House briefing room. It's the place where he announces policy and delivers his message to the American people. And it's also the place where he, often gleefully, tries to skewer his political opponents.

As the House Democrats' impeachment inquiry continues and Trump's own reelection efforts gather speed, an NPR analysis shows that Trump's broadsides against Democrats in Congress have intensified since July. And his language about nonwhite lawmakers has also grown more heated.

NPR examined Trump's tweets, both positive and negative, about every single current member of Congress starting from his Inauguration Day until last week. As of Oct. 4, Trump had tweeted more than 700 times about sitting members of Congress.

While Trump has always spread his insults far and wide, the volume of personal insults and extreme language that he directed at the so-called "squad" of four Democratic congresswomen and African American Rep. Elijah Cummings over the summer stood out.

He kicked off his tweetstorm in mid-July with a Twitter thread that embraced racist tropes, urging members of the "squad" — all women of color — to "go back" to the "totally broken and crime infested places from which they came."

Trump would go on to tweet about the "squad" — Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts and Rashida Tlaib of Michigan — nearly 20 times collectively in about three months.

That's more negative tweets than Trump has aimed at presidential candidates Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders in the nearly three years he has been president.

Among other things, he has called the squad "a very racist group of troublemakers" and claimed they hate the United States.

That language speaks to some white Trump supporters who may be worried about the country's changing demographics, says Niambi Carter, a political science professor at Howard University.

"When he says 'Make America Great Again' and points to these women as the sort of embodiment of everything that America isn't: It's not black. It's not a woman. It's not Muslim. It's not Latina ... these women become perfect vehicles for all of that xenophobia and all of that anxiety that these white voters feel," Carter said.

Omar, in particular, has been a top target for Trump on Twitter and off. Including tweets about the "squad" and tweets that single her out, Trump has tweeted about her 29 times. By comparison, he tweeted about Ocasio-Cortez 22 times.

Trump is holding a rally in the heart of Omar's district in Minneapolis on Thursday. At a campaign rally in North Carolina in July, the crowd echoed Trump's tweets and chanted "send her back" about Omar, who was born in Somalia, but is an American citizen.

These sorts of attacks have a long running history, said Pearl Dowe, a political science and African American studies professor at Emory University.

"This is an ongoing struggle for people of color to have their citizenship respected, to actually live out their full citizenship, but also their humanity as well," Dowe said.

"The president chooses his targets pretty carefully"

The White House did not respond to interview requests for this story, but Trump supporters generally say that the president is a counterpuncher who responds to people who attack him, no matter who they are.

The review of Trump's tweets shows that he does go after critics, but not everyone gets the same treatment or attention.

The only lawmakers with more negative tweets than the squad and Cummings are top Democrats: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff.

Other lawmakers who regularly criticize Trump, like former presidential candidate Eric Swalwell, barely get a mention in the president's Twitter feed. The same is true for senators and presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Cory Booker.

"The president chooses his targets pretty carefully but he doesn't always choose them for the same reason," said Brian Ott, a communications professor at Texas Tech University and co-author of The Twitter Presidency.

Ott said Trump uses Twitter to discredit politicians he views as a threat and to distract from other matters.

"There's this other motivation, which is trying to define the opposition, and it's clear that he takes tremendous pleasure and is particularly vitriolic when it comes to characterizing women and ethnic minorities on Twitter," he said.

On Twitter, Trump has said the face of the Democratic Party is the "squad," Pelosi and Rep. Maxine Waters, who is African American.

He has never extended that label "face of the Democrat Party" to a white male lawmaker.

When Trump does set his Twitter sights on an opponent, the nature of the attacks can vary sharply depending on who the critic is.

Trump has tweeted about Schiff 41 times, with many of those mentions coming in the past three weeks as the impeachment inquiry has gotten underway. The president has accused Schiff of committing treason and being a fraud.

But Trump's tweets about Schiff have focused on his actions as the chair of a committee probing the president. In contrast, Trump's tweets about Cummings — who is chair of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform — focused on the mostly black district that he represents in and around Baltimore. Trump called the area "rat and rodent infested."

Trump launched similar attacks against districts represented by Pelosi and Rep. John Lewis in the past.

Paris Dennard is a prominent African American conservative who backs Trump. He argued that it's not race or gender that motivates the president, but the prominence of the critic.

"If you are a worthy opponent, meaning you have a large social media following ... meaning you can attract a lot of people to whatever it is you're talking about ... he's going to engage with them because he thinks it's worth the fight," Dennard said.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

When President Trump holds a campaign rally today in Minneapolis, Minn., he will be inside the congressional district of a lawmaker he often criticizes. It is the district of Democrat Ilhan Omar. NPR's Ayesha Rascoe has been looking at the president's Twitter feed, where he has criticized Omar, among many other people. She found the president's attacks on lawmakers are growing more personal, especially against people of color.

AYESHA RASCOE, BYLINE: President Trump's tweets can set the wheels of government in motion and set the tone for his supporters. Back in July, Trump was eagerly attacking Ilhan Omar at a rally in Greenville, N.C.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Omar has a history of launching vicious anti-Semitic screeds.

RASCOE: In response, the crowd chanted, send her back.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED TRUMP SUPPORTERS: (Chanting) Send her back. Send her back...

RASCOE: Omar was born in Somalia but is an American citizen. The chants were prompted by Trump's tweets a few days earlier. Using racist language, Trump tweeted that Omar and three other Democrats - all women of color - known as the squad should go back to the, quote, "totally broken and crime-infested places from which they came."

Trump has always used Twitter as a weapon against his political opponents. But these tweets and the dozens that would come in the weeks following against the squad and against African American Congressman Elijah Cummings represented an escalation of the president's attacks.

(SOUNDBITE OF MONTAGE)

TRUMP: These are people that, in my opinion, hate our country.

And AOC plus 3, that's what I call it.

Elijah Cummings has not helped the people.

If you're not happy here, then you can leave.

RASCOE: NPR examined Trump's tweets about members of Congress through October 4. Since becoming president, Trump has tweeted more than 700 times about current lawmakers. While Trump hasn't been restrained about insults, his negative tweets have increased in volume. And the nature of insults have become more extreme since July.

In the case of the squad, which includes Omar, Ayanna Pressley, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Rashida Tlaib, Trump has tweeted about them collectively nearly 20 times in about three months. That's more negative tweets than Trump has aimed at presidential candidates Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders. Among other things, he's called the squad a very racist group of troublemakers. That language speaks to some white Trump supporters who may be worried about their place in America, says Niambi Carter. She's a political science professor at Howard University.

NIAMBI CARTER: When he says make America great again and points to these women as the sort of embodiment of everything that America isn't - it's not black, it's not a woman, it's not Muslim, it's not Latina - these women become perfect vehicles for all of that anxiety that these white voters feel.

RASCOE: The only lawmakers with more negative tweets than the squad and Cummings are top Democrats - House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff. But his tweets about them are more general criticisms about the Democratic Party.

BRIAN OTT: The president chooses his targets pretty carefully, but he doesn't always choose them for the same reason.

RASCOE: That's Brian Ott, a communications professor at Texas Tech University and co-author of "The Twitter Presidency." He says Trump uses Twitter to discredit politicians he views as a threat and to distract from other matters.

OTT: Then there's this other motivation, which is trying to define the opposition. And it's clear that he takes tremendous pleasure and is particularly vitriolic when it comes to characterizing women and ethnic minorities on Twitter.

RASCOE: On Twitter, Trump says the face of the Democratic Party is the squad, Pelosi and Congresswoman Maxine Waters, who is African American. He never says white men are the face of the Democratic Party. The White House didn't respond to interview requests, but Trump's supporters argue he's a counterpuncher. Paris Dennard is a prominent African American conservative who backs Trump. He said it's not race or gender that motivates the president.

PARIS DENNARD: If you are a worthy opponent - meaning you have a large social media following, meaning you can attract a lot of people to whatever it is you're talking about - he is going to engage with them because he thinks it's worth the fight.

RASCOE: Trump has targeted both Cummings, who is chair of the House Oversight Committee, and Schiff with a flood of tweets. But while the tweets against Schiff have focused on his actions as chairman, Trump's tweets against Cummings focus on the mostly black district he represents in Baltimore. Ott says the rhetoric about Cummings in particular is meant to set him apart as different.

OTT: The president's discussion of Baltimore as rat-infested is really meant to convey that he's not quite human.

RASCOE: With an impeachment probe in full swing, the president has tweeted about the squad less. Cummings hasn't gotten a mention in weeks. But Trump hasn't forgotten about these lawmakers. He told reporters on Friday that AOC plus three, as he likes to call the squad, are the real leaders of the Democratic Party.

Ayesha Rascoe, NPR News, Washington.

(SOUNDBITE OF THRUPENCE'S "FOREST ON THE SUN") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.